Muslim World

‘Robert Spencer’: An Islam-Hating Dustbin

By Naushad Akhtar

A small and very simple question: Can a person who has written 32 books be irrational, intellect-deficient, and speak like a fool? Naturally, your answer would be no. But that is not the case here. There is one such person whose name is Robert Spencer. According to the bio provided on his X (formerly Twitter) profile: “He runs a propaganda website named Jihad Watch. He claims to be the author of 32 books, including The History of Jihad, The Critical Quran, Stealth Jihad, The Palestinian Delusion, The Tragedy of Islam, etc., all of which are stated to be available on Amazon.”

This foolish author named Robert has published three articles/reports about FlyDubai on his website. Naturally, since he is running a full-fledged campaign against Islam and Muslims, one can easily imagine the level of one-sidedness and sheer foolishness embedded in his reports. Consider a sample from one of the reports by this fool who has written 32 books: “A plumber learned how to fly a plane by watching TV, and with the help of a few passengers, he managed to land the FlyDubai plane safely.”

Is this even possible? Can someone become such an expert and sharp pilot just by watching videos on TV that they know where to land the plane, what kind of signals and language codes to follow, and can a plumber so easily fly and safely land a Boeing carrying 174 passengers? Both pilots of FlyDubai were highly experienced with thousands of nautical miles of flight experience.

Robert Spencer, who is filled with hatred towards Islam, calls this ‘interesting’ in his report, but as a foolish author publishing an article titled “Half of the Airline Pilots Who Intentionally Crashed Planes Were Muslim” on his website, he neither raises such basic questions in his report nor mentions that a plane plummeting nose-first at high speed could burst under atmospheric pressure. Nor is it recorded in this fool’s report that if the plane was diving nose-down, how were passengers seen walking around so easily in the viral video from the plane, and why didn’t a glass full of water placed behind a seat fall over? Readers might as well ask whether all the flying clubs in the world providing flight training should close down and start teaching plumbing instead!!

Here are all three reports from this fool’s website presented below; let the readers read them and try to understand how much garbage must be filled inside his 32 books!!

1. ‘The Goal Is Islam’: Airline Pilot Reveals Motive Behind Hijacking to Stunned Newscaster

I suspect Australia’s ‘News24’ (whose slogan is “Trusted News First”) won’t be inviting Captain Byron Bailey back anytime soon. He is a veteran airline pilot and former RAAF (Royal Australian Air Force) pilot who was brought on air to explain the FlyDubai hijacking incident.

Well, the Captain laid it out straight and clear.

Perhaps News24 wasn’t looking for that particular answer. News24 had originally covered the event as: “A flight heading to Israel with 150 people on board was diverted to Saudi Arabia following a fight between the pilots” (framing it as a suicide attempt rather than a hijacking). At the same time, their current headlines include stories like “Palestinian Killed in Settler Violence for Second Consecutive Day.”

Unfortunate for them. Though wrapped in a bit of dark humor, the audience got to hear the truth anyway.

2. Half of the Airline Pilots Who Intentionally Crashed Planes Were Muslim

Passenger airline crashes are uncommon, intentional crashes are extremely rare, and deliberate pilot-induced crashes are almost unheard of. Passenger planes are generally flown by highly trained airline pilots; many are seasoned veterans from their respective air forces who remain calm under pressure.

Lessons from the FlyDubai Incident

An attempt by a co-pilot to crash a FlyDubai plane carrying 174 Israeli passengers somewhere in Israel was thwarted. Despite being injured, the captain managed to open the cockpit door, and four Israeli passengers rushed in to subdue the co-pilot. One of those four, a plumber by profession, succeeded in stabilizing the aircraft because—as he later explained—he had learned what to do from watching television shows. Subsequently, one of two off-duty pilots among the passengers took command and landed the plane safely in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. It is a fascinating story from which several lessons can be drawn. Further insights on these lessons can be found in Herb Keinon’s article “The FlyDubai Incident Illustrates Israel’s Role in the New Middle East and Its Old Boundaries”.

An Emirati airline carrying Israelis landed in Saudi Arabia for an emergency amid a broader conflict involving Iran—and the event instantly became a centerpiece of Israel’s election campaign, where the core debate centers on who can keep the country safe.

Talk about an incident containing every conceivable element.

Beyond the terrifying sequence of events inside the aircraft, this incident highlighted another reality: how drastically the region has transformed, and where the limits of that transformation lie.

Israelis were flying home on an Emirati airline. When their flight turned into a nightmare, they landed in Saudi Arabia, received medical care and assistance, and were eventually brought back to Israel on a second Emirati aircraft.

Despite the underlying tensions, war, and political sensitivity, this chain of events is remarkable. Even without official Saudi-Israeli diplomatic ties, the passengers were given aid and brought home safely.

Granted, Saudi Arabia did not permit an Israeli plane to land and pick them up. That is significant and frustrating, especially given the existing security and intelligence cooperation between the two nations. However, that shouldn’t eclipse what they did permit, nor should the narrative of regional cooperation be reduced solely to a story of refusal…

Still, Israel-UAE relations will undoubtedly weather this shock. A relationship that has survived the events of October 7 and the ensuing conflicts in Gaza, Lebanon, and Iran is built on interests that a single hijacking attempt cannot rattle. If anything, the incident underscores the shared threats both nations face, why they need each other, and how they can assist one another.

The Omani co-pilot, Hammam al-Hammami, a radicalized Muslim who—as he posted online—was intent on killing Jews, is aligned with terrorists seeking to overthrow the UAE government. They target the UAE because its government is moderate, opposes terrorism, has banned the Muslim Brotherhood, and seeks stronger ties with the Jewish state.

Saudi Arabia has benefited for years from Israeli intelligence, even if the relationship remains discreet so the Saudi government avoids becoming a target for angry Muslims opposed to any ties with Israel. Nevertheless, this relationship explains why Saudi Arabia permitted a FlyDubai plane packed with Israelis to land on its soil and assisted those passengers upon arrival.

The UAE will have many questions to answer. How was an Omani pilot authorized to fly a route to Tel Aviv when the Israeli government had previously made it clear to the UAE that only pilots from countries with diplomatic ties to Israel should fly to Israel? Oman has no diplomatic relations with Israel. Was someone in charge of pilot vetting in the UAE extraordinarily negligent, or was it something worse—an accomplice deliberately participating in a plot to crash a plane carrying Israeli passengers? We will find out soon enough.

This explains why there has not been a single instance of an American airline pilot intentionally crashing a plane, and only one recorded case of a Western airline plane being brought down with everyone on board. That occurred in 2015, when a suicidal first officer intentionally crashed Germanwings Flight 9525, operated by Lufthansa.

The only other case involving a Western pilot (though not a Western airline) was the crash of Mozambique Airlines Flight TM470 in Africa, carried out by a Portuguese pilot. All remaining cases involved non-Western pilots, including two Asian and four Muslim pilots who intentionally crashed or attempted to crash commercial planes. This includes the first known instance of an airline pilot intentionally crashing a passenger jet in 1994, when Captain Younes Khayati intentionally disengaged the autopilot on Royal Air Maroc Flight 630 and flew the plane into a mountain.

The list of suicidal Muslim pilots also includes EgyptAir Flight 990 in 1999, where the first officer repeatedly shouted “Allahu Akbar” while driving the plane down into the ocean. Additionally, Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 belongs on this list; despite generating wild conspiracy theories ranging from UFOs to black holes, it was likely the deliberate act of Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah. Following the FlyDubai incident—where an Omani Muslim pilot stabbed an Indian pilot in an attempt to hijack and potentially crash Flight FZ1073 bound for Israel—the number of Muslim pilots who attempted to bring down airplanes has risen to 4.

This means that 44% of all pilots who intentionally crashed or attempted to crash airplanes were Muslim.

These statistics are even more striking considering that Muslim pilots and airlines represent a very small fraction of the global airline travel sector. Asian and North American markets combined account for 66% of total flights, Europe accounts for 23%, Africa just around 3%, and the Middle East a mere 5%. Despite this, the proportion of deliberate pilot crashes coming from the Middle East and Africa is disproportionately high relative to their flight volume.

This alarming statistic—that nearly half of all pilots trying to crash their own aircraft were Muslim—does not even factor in conventional hijackings (such as the September 11 Islamic terrorist attacks) or other hijacking attempts; it is strictly limited to airline pilots who intentionally crashed commercial passenger planes.

If we factor in hijackings, the 9/11 attacks alone would make the record of Muslim pilots far worse, as those were the deadliest instances of commercial jets being weaponized to cause maximum destruction and loss of life, regardless of their illegal and illegitimate nature.

This recent incident raises grave questions regarding the risks associated with Muslim pilots and Muslim airlines operating in the US and other targeted destinations of terrorism.

When EgyptAir Flight 990 crashed near Nantucket, allegations of ‘Islamophobia’ were raised when investigators noted the alarming chants about ‘Allah’ on the cockpit voice recorder, even though this crash occurred prior to 9/11. The Egyptians initially refused to hand over control of the investigation, sending experts to explain Islamic theology to the Americans. We were assured that when First Officer Gamil al-Batouti took control while the captain was in the lavatory and forced the plane into a nose-dive while invoking “Allah,” it was entirely normal behavior. It was later established that al-Batouti had deliberately crashed the plane. Egypt refused to accept this, and getting close to the truth required immense effort alongside the defecting attempt of another Egyptian pilot. Even then, suspicions lingered that it was a terrorist act, but due to the political sensitivities surrounding the crash, no definitive proof was ever published, confirmed, or openly debated.

Had the FlyDubai situation ended in a crash, a similar cover-up would likely have taken place. Instead, Israeli passengers breached the cockpit, subdued the attacking pilot, and allowed other qualified crew members to take control. However, it is unlikely that authorities on the ground (currently the Saudis) will ever allow the full truth of what transpired in the air to emerge.

It remains unknown how many of these intentional crashes by Muslim pilots were driven by pilot-led terrorism, primarily because the Muslim nations involved have consistently avoided discussing the underlying motives.

3. Lessons from the FlyDubai Incident

An attempt by a co-pilot to crash a FlyDubai plane carrying 174 Israeli passengers somewhere in Israel was thwarted. Despite being injured, the captain managed to open the cockpit door, and four Israeli passengers rushed in to subdue the co-pilot. One of those four, a plumber by profession, succeeded in stabilizing the aircraft because—as he later explained—he had learned what to do from watching television shows. Subsequently, one of two off-duty pilots among the passengers took command and landed the plane safely in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. It is a fascinating story from which several lessons can be drawn. Further insights on these lessons can be found in Herb Keinon’s article “The FlyDubai Incident Illustrates Israel’s Role in the New Middle East and Its Old Boundaries” – Jerusalem Post, October 2, 2026:

An Emirati airline carrying Israelis landed in Saudi Arabia for an emergency amid a broader conflict involving Iran—and the event instantly became a centerpiece of Israel’s election campaign, where the core debate centers on who can keep the country safe.

Talk about an incident containing every conceivable element.

Beyond the terrifying sequence of events inside the aircraft, this incident highlighted another reality: how drastically the region has transformed, and where the limits of that transformation lie.

Israelis were flying home on an Emirati airline. When their flight turned into a nightmare, they landed in Saudi Arabia, received medical care and assistance, and were eventually brought back to Israel on a second Emirati aircraft.

Despite the underlying tensions, war, and political sensitivity, this chain of events is remarkable. Even without official Saudi-Israeli diplomatic ties, the passengers were given aid and brought home safely.

Granted, Saudi Arabia did not permit an Israeli plane to land and pick them up. That is significant and frustrating, especially given the existing security and intelligence cooperation between the two nations. However, that shouldn’t eclipse what they did permit, nor should the narrative of regional cooperation be reduced solely to a story of refusal…

Still, Israel-UAE relations will undoubtedly weather this shock. A relationship that has survived the events of October 7 and the ensuing conflicts in Gaza, Lebanon, and Iran is built on interests that a single hijacking attempt cannot rattle. If anything, the incident underscores the shared threats both nations face, why they need each other, and how they can assist one another.

The Omani co-pilot, Hammam al-Hammami, a radicalized Muslim who—as he posted online—was intent on killing Jews, is aligned with terrorists seeking to overthrow the UAE government. They target the UAE because its government is moderate, opposes terrorism, has banned the Muslim Brotherhood, and seeks stronger ties with the Jewish state.

Saudi Arabia has benefited for years from Israeli intelligence, even if the relationship remains discreet so the Saudi government avoids becoming a target for angry Muslims opposed to any ties with Israel. Nevertheless, this relationship explains why Saudi Arabia permitted a FlyDubai plane packed with Israelis to land on its soil and assisted those passengers upon arrival.

The UAE will have many questions to answer. How was an Omani pilot authorized to fly a route to Tel Aviv when the Israeli government had previously made it clear to the UAE that only pilots from countries with diplomatic ties to Israel should fly to Israel? Oman has no diplomatic relations with Israel. Was someone in charge of pilot vetting in the UAE extraordinarily negligent, or was it something worse—an accomplice deliberately participating in a plot to crash a plane carrying Israeli passengers? We will find out soon enough.